A History Teacher, An Obsession With A Sunken Ship, And The Crew Searching For Its Wreck

Shipwreck hunters Jeff Groth, right, and Scott Williams methodically towed a magnetometer back and forth over a search grid -- "mowing the lawn," as they called it. CREDIT: TOM BANSE / NW NEWS NETWORK
Shipwreck hunters Jeff Groth, right, and Scott Williams methodically towed a magnetometer back and forth over a search grid -- "mowing the lawn," as they called it. CREDIT: TOM BANSE / NW NEWS NETWORK

Less than 200 years ago, the easiest way to get around a lot of the Pacific Northwest was by canoe. The first American steamship to provide regular service among Puget Sound ports arrived in 1853.

This small steamship, propelled by paddlewheels attached to its sides, was called the Fairy. But its success was short-lived. It soon blew up and sank.

Today, an Oregon-based group of shipwreck hunters wants to find the historic remains of that little steamer. The shipwreck search was inspired by  one man’s obsession. Appropriately enough, he’s nicknamed “Tug.”

Michael “Tug” Buse of Port Townsend, Washington, teaches history and social studies by day. He described himself as captivated by maritime history in his spare time — and by steamboats, in particular.

“I discovered this tiny little side-wheeler,” Buse said. “I just became infatuated with her. So I’ve been researching her now for almost five years.”

The Fairy‘s short life began with the California Gold Rush and ended with an 1857 boiler explosion as she was leaving the Steilacoom wharf for Olympia. In between, the side-wheeler made history.

Beginning in 1853, the roughly 30-foot-long steamer offered the first scheduled service between Olympia (population about 50 to 100) and the brand new settlement of Seattle with intermediate stops in Steilacoom and Alki.  Traces of the historic Steilacoom wharf can still be found today at very low tides.

The explosion on Oct. 22, 1857 injured all on board except the engineer. Luckily, no one lost their life when the diminutive Fairy sank to the bottom of the Sound.

Puget Sound steamers would eventually become so numerous that they resembled a swarm of mosquitos for a time. Those steamers became known as the “Mosquito Fleet” during passenger steamship service that lasted from the 1850s to 1930s.

Buse, the history teacher, credits the Fairy as the Mosquito Fleet’s founding member.

The historical significance of the Fairymade Buse want to find the wreck. It didn’t take much convincing of the right people to help him.

Enter an all-volunteer group centered in Astoria and Portland called the Maritime Archaeological Society.

Chris Dewey, president of the group, boarded one of three inflatables launched on a recent Saturday to scan the seafloor just off the Steilacoom shore. It was a sunny, calm day in early August, ideal for towing a torpedo-shaped magnetometer back and forth. The device detects iron or steel on the seafloor.

“We are now looking for the metal parts of that steamer — being the boiler, the engine and probably most of the paddlewheels,” Dewey said. 

A second boat team surveyed the bottom with sonar. A third team stood by with an underwater robot video camera (also known as a tethered remotely operated vehicle, or ROV) to investigate promising targets.

The boat crews hailed one another over hand-held radios as they slowly followed search grid tracklines.

“See something, Scott?” crackled the radio. “Nothing too exciting yet,” came the response.

There’s no prospect of gold or silver treasure to motivate the shipwreck hunters in this case. The volunteers included a cartographer, a retired Navy officer, a professional archaeologist, as well as people interested in shipwrecks as a hobby.

“I love the sea so any excuse to have to go to the beach, especially if you’re doing something with purpose instead of just going to hang out,” explained Jennifer Kozik of Portland. “I’m not working in archaeology. It’s more my passion, which I just sort of do on the side.”

The shipwreck would probably be considered a state-owned archaeological site if Kozik and friends find the Fairy where they are looking.

The methodical hours-long search identified three underwater objects that bear further investigation. The deepest is about 90 feet down and the others are at about 60 feet deep. Dewey, of the Maritime Archaeological Society, says a close-up inspection with divers comes next — probably in the fall.

If his team finds the wreck, Dewey’s intention is to thoroughly survey and document it. Still, they would leave the likely-corroded remnants of the ship in place, taking only a possible “diagnostic” artifact that could prove the wreck is the long-lost Fairy.

Dewey’s team has found and documented wrecks in the ocean and along the Columbia River. But the hunt for the Fairy, the team’s first effort in Puget Sound, continues. 

 To learn more about the Fairy, you can attend a presentation that Michael “Tug” Buse is giving this coming Saturday as part of the “Brigade Encampment” event at Fort Nisqually.

What: Historical talk about the pioneer steamship Fairy with model and small steam engine
When: 12:30 p.m., Saturday, August 11
Where: Fort Nisqually, Point Defiance Park, Tacoma
Admission: $10-$15
For more info visit Metro Parks Tacoma’s website. 

Related Stories:

The Eagle Saloon in the 1870s. This building still stands in Jacksonville, but the adjacent Wetterer home and the brewery behind it is gone.

Craft Brewing In The Pacific NW Dates So Far Back That Archaeologists Are On The Case

The Pacific Northwest is rightfully proud of its thriving microbrewery scene. Most beer lovers probably consider the rise of craft brewing a phenomenon of the past few decades. But the first brewpubs in the Northwest date so far back that archaeologists were called in to excavate the remnants of one in Jacksonville, Oregon. Continue Reading Craft Brewing In The Pacific NW Dates So Far Back That Archaeologists Are On The Case