Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Reeder's Reviews: The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping

Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in 'The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.'
Lionsgate
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in 'The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.'

“Nothing is inevitable.”

That recurring line–indeed, a kind of mantra–from the sixth installment in the Hunger Games franchise resonates in both hopeful and cynical ways. It also belies the mathematics of a blockbuster movie series, where geometry definitely matters. As this franchise’s second prequel, it has to slot into place as seamlessly as possible. That it does.

Let’s start with its greatest strengths. It looks spectacular, with its combination of distinctive (retro and futuristic) interiors, outdoor forests and vistas, and lavish–in some cases, outlandish–costumes. It often pops with color, and its CGI creatures, many of which embody danger, have an exquisite artistry.

The director Francis Lawrence, a veteran of this series, possesses an undeniable instinct for framing the action set pieces in a consistently effective way. And, during the “reaping” scene for the 50th Games, when the unfortunate young contestants for this lethal competition are chosen at random from their respective districts, the camera emulates the attendees in scanning the venue for them, waiting for them to step forward, however reluctantly.

Like any prequel, The Hunger Games: SOTR starts at a disadvantage. Franchise regulars already know what’s going to happen to the principal characters (24 years later, in this case), as well as what’s going to happen to the sovereign, post-nuclear, North American country of Panem. That imposes real challenges on the screenwriter, director and cast.

Alas, this film suffers from a significant lack of formal, conceptual and thematic development. The relatively few combat sequences, replete with the usual “eliminations,” play out rather abruptly, with not a great deal of suspense. Likewise, the television broadcasts from the Capitol impart the same messages, almost, just with different actors this time.

An impressive cast populates The Hunger Games: SOTR, comprising fresh faces and established veterans alike. Since this is essentially the origin story of Haymitch Abernathy, Australian actor Joseph Zada is the main focus of attention. Most recently seen in the streaming series East of Eden, he has strong screen presence and a genuinely affecting quality in the love scenes with the Ugandan-Canadian actress Whitney Peak (Molly’s Game) as Lenore Dove Baird. For much of the picture, though, his work seems a little too studied and often slightly off-key, either underplaying or overplaying many moments.

Multiple Academy Award nominee Ralph Fiennes (Conclave, The English Patient, Schindler’s List) assumes the imperious role of President Snow. While he certainly has the necessary gravitas, he plays the part more subtly than the late Donald Sutherland in the original tetralogy. That serves him well, especially in a pivotal scene when he licks his bloody fingers. That chills, in just the right way.

Kieran Culkin, an Oscar winner last year for A Real Pain, brings the requisite flamboyance to the role of television host-impresario-propagandist Caesar Flickerman. The versatile, estimable Glenn Close appears as Drusilla Sickle, the cold-hearted District 12 escort, her look deliberately distorted by prosthetics, surgical tape and wig cap, with her exaggerated mouth, teeth and nose worthy of a caricature. Mckenna Grace assumes the dual roles of the rebellious Maysilee Donner and her sweeter twin sister, Merrilee.

Along with Zada in the lead, perhaps the actor who registers most in the movie, both in terms of his character and talent, is the always reliable Jesse Plemons (Kinds of Kindness, Killers of the Flower Moon). His portrayal of Plutarch Heavensbee–cameraman, mentor, mediator and covert rebel–helps give the narrative a serious, mature through-line. Small sacrifices and victories, he counsels Haymitch, have value.

Suzanne Collins, who began her career as a children’s television writer for PBS and Nickelodeon, has found a very receptive global audience for her series of young adult dystopian fiction novels. With its star-studded cast (including several cameos), visually sumptuous tableaux, and a lushly orchestrated score by James Newton Howard, Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping has box office success written all over it. Despite its structural weaknesses, it manages to reinforce the other pictures in the series, but in an even darker, more insidious way. Its recurring themes of family, class, love, honor, violence, survival and tyranny remain topical in 2026–not to mention its view of mass media. As Haymitch learns to his dismay, heroism doesn’t necessarily win the Games; savage cunning does. Put that on a poster, while you appreciate how Joseph Zada morphs into Woody Harrelson.

A native of Seattle and a University of Washington graduate, Steve Reeder began his life in radio at KUOW-FM, while still in his teens. He has since worked on two separate occasions at KING-FM there, first as Program Director and later as a staff announcer, producer, and interviewer. In between, Steve spent nine valuable and highly enjoyable years at WFMT-FM in Chicago, where he had the good fortune to work alongside the likes of the late Studs Terkel, and where he (quite by coincidence) had the opportunity to play the very first CD on American radio. In case you’re wondering, it was a Tuesday evening, and it was the opening section of Richard Strauss’ “Also sprach Zarathustra.”