There’s Another Multimillion Dollar Jury Settlement Against Amtrak Following 2017 I-5 Derailment

Cars from an Amtrak train lie spilled onto Interstate 5 below alongside smashed vehicles as some train cars remain on the tracks in DuPont, Washington. CREDIT: ELAINE THOMPSON/AP
Cars from an Amtrak train lie spilled onto Interstate 5 below alongside smashed vehicles as some train cars remain on the tracks in DuPont, Washington. CREDIT: ELAINE THOMPSON/AP


Another passenger badly injured in the Amtrak train derailment south of Tacoma nearly two years ago will collect big-time damages. But suing Amtrak like this suburban Seattle woman did will no longer be an option after future crashes.

An eight-member federal court jury on Wednesday ordered Amtrak to pay Madeleine Garza of Maple Valley, Washington, $4.5 million for pain, suffering and possible future disabilities. Garza received spinal injuries and broke her pelvis during the derailment of the speeding Amtrak Cascades train, which was traveling from Seattle to Portland.

Garza was an 18-year-old community college student at the time. She was riding in the middle of the train in one of the cars that tumbled from a freeway overpass and flipped over on Interstate 5 near DuPont.

“Maddie was thrilled with the verdict,” said Garza’s lead attorney, Darrell Cochran, after leaving the courthouse in Tacoma. “In particular, she is thrilled to put this dark chapter behind her and continue moving forward to enjoy life.”

Her civil lawsuit was the second to go to a jury stemming from the catastrophic crash on Dec. 18, 2017. Wednesday’s verdict followed a nearly $17 million jury award in early September. Two badly injured men and the wife of one of them will split that.

In total, more than 35 people have sued Amtrak for damages connected to the derailment in which three people died and more than 60 were injured. At least one case involving an injured technician for train maker Talgo settled under terms that were kept private.

RELATED: Amtrak Concedes Negligence In Deadly 2017 Derailment 

The next Amtrak derailment-related personal injury lawsuit trial starts next week in Tacoma. The plaintiff in that case is a freeway driver whose car was partially crushed by a falling rail car.

Amtrak conceded negligence for the DuPont wreck at the outset of the first trial and in Garza’s case. So, the testimony this week and last focused on Garza’s injuries and recovery. In this month’s cases and the bellwether one, U.S. District Court Judge Benjamin Settle allowed the plaintiffs to ask for compensatory damages, but ruled that their attempts to seek additional punitive damages were not permitted under the laws governing Amtrak.

Early this year, Amtrak changed the terms and conditions for ticket purchases to require mandatory arbitration for passenger claims — up to and including serious injuries and wrongful death. So, if there is another catastrophic derailment in the future, you won’t see a parade of lawsuits in federal court like there is now.

Pierce County Executive Bruce Dammeier and Gov. Jay Inslee

At a 2017 news conference at the crash site, Pierce County Executive Bruce Dammeier was asked about his confidence in Amtrak’s safety record in his county. Washington Gov. Jay Inslee, left, also attended. CREDIT: TOM BANSE/N3

During a Congressional oversight hearing on Capitol Hill Wednesday, House Transportation Committee Chair Peter DeFazio (D-Oregon) asked Amtrak CEO Richard Anderson about the appropriateness of the “pretty tough” arbitration clause.

Anderson replied that the legal language his railway adopted is fairly standard in corporate America these days.

“Arbitration actually is faster,” Anderson told DeFazio. “It gives all the same remedies.”

“We want to be a customer-friendly railroad,” Anderson continued. “But at the same time we want to have an efficient, lawful method for promptly and fairly resolving any passenger claims.”

Trial lawyer groups dislike the spread of mandatory arbitration in ticket contracts because they believe the clauses reduce transparency, shield negligence from disclosure, preclude class actions and can result in smaller payouts to victims.

A final investigation report released by the National Transportation Safety Board earlier this year found the Amtrak Cascades wreck could have been prevented. The immediate cause of the derailment was that the locomotive engineer failed to slow the train ahead of a sharp curve, but the NTSB cited crew training deficiencies and numerous other risk mitigation steps that the board said Amtrak, track owner Sound Transit and the Washington State Department of Transportation should have taken.

During Wednesday’s Congressional hearing, Anderson touted improved safety including the implementation of an automated emergency braking system that federal regulators have long wanted. The technology, formally known as positive train control, is now operational on all passenger trains in the Pacific Northwest.

“If you look across our safety statistics, we had significant improvement in all of the key safety metrics across Amtrak” over the past year, Anderson told the House committee.

An Amtrak spokesperson did not have an immediate comment on the jury verdict later in the day Wednesday.

The deadly derailment happened on what was to be the first day of more frequent Amtrak service between Seattle and Portland. Washington state was all set to subsidize six daily roundtrips — up from four — using a new, faster bypass route south of Tacoma.

WSDOT rail division director Ron Pate has told public radio and state legislators that the ratcheted-back service will remain on the older, congested routing along the Puget Sound shoreline until his agency and Amtrak can acquire replacement railcars that meet the latest safety standards.

Pate said there is also more work to do to convince the communities on the bypass route — chiefly Lakewood and DuPont — that a resumption of faster train trips can be operated safely. This summer, the Pierce County Council and Lakewood City Council voted unanimously to oppose resumption of fast rail service on the Point Defiance Bypass until all 26 NTSB-recommended safety improvements are made.

The number of outstanding issues makes it unlikely that passenger-carrying Amtrak Cascades trains will return to the line where the 2017 derailment occurred any sooner than next spring.

Related Stories:

Amtrak train derailment onto Interstate 5 - Picture 2

Amtrak Concedes Negligence In Deadly 2017 Derailment Over I-5 Near Tacoma

The crash on Dec. 18, 2017, killed three passengers and injured 65 others, including people on board the speeding train and motorists on adjacent Interstate 5. Amtrak asserted the only question the jury would need to wrestle with is “what is fair and reasonable compensation.”